Where the two jobs overlap, and where they do not

The two jobs overlap in the plumbing and diverge in the evidence. Both need a site that crawlers can fetch, structured data that names the business, and pages that load. Beyond that they part ways. SEO earns a position in a list through relevance, links and technical health. AI visibility earns a mention in an answer through entity recognition and the evidence a page carries.

The divergence is measurable. Across 1,000 consumer ranking queries, the domains GPT-4o cited had a median overlap of 0.0 percent with Google's top ten, in the University of Toronto analysis presented at EDBT/ICDT 2026; the other engines overlapped by 11 to 15 percent. Kargaev's SEO-to-GEO synthesis draws the practical conclusion: ranking fitness and citation fitness are now two separate pieces of work, even when they touch the same page.

Why Google's AI still needs your SEO agency

Google's AI features still need classic SEO because they are built on the organic index. Google's own guidance says no special schema, llms.txt file or AI-specific format is required for AI Overviews, and that optimising for its generative features is still SEO. Industry analysis cited in the same synthesis finds that AI Overviews typically include at least one top organic result. If you are not indexed and eligible, you are not in the pool.

The stakes on that side have grown. In the United States, 67 percent of Google queries returned an AI Overview in 2025, up from 42 percent a year earlier, according to Aral, Li and Zuo at MIT. When a summary appears, only 8 percent of visits click a traditional result against 15 percent without one, in Pew Research Center's tracking of 68,879 searches. Ranking still decides who is eligible; the summary decides who is seen.

Why your SEO agency alone will not get you named by ChatGPT

An SEO agency alone will not get you named by ChatGPT because the signals that decide a mention there are not the ones an SEO retainer buys. In Ahrefs' analysis of 75,000 brands, mentions of the brand across the web correlated more strongly with AI visibility than Domain Rating. In the founding KDD 2024 experiments, adding statistics, citations and quotations raised visibility in generative answers by up to 40 percent, while keyword tactics did little. Link building and keyword density are SEO deliverables; entity mentions and sourced evidence are not on that invoice.

There is also the measurement gap. Only 34 to 42 percent of the sources an AI engine cites stay the same from one day to the next, so reliable tracking needs at least seven runs per prompt. A rankings dashboard cannot report that, and an agency that has never built the measurement will not notice the mention rate moving.

One team or two: the honest comparison

Two agencies One team, two reports
Crawler access, structured data, speed Done twice or argued over Done once
Page edits Two editors on the same page, different goals One editor, evidence and relevance together
Reporting Rankings in one deck, mentions in another Side by side, same month, same pages
Accountability Each blames the other's changes One owner
Cost Overlap paid twice Overlap paid once
Risk Neither sees the whole picture One team can still be weak at one job

The last row is the honest caveat. One team is only better if it can actually do both. The nine questions for choosing an AI search agency apply to an SEO agency claiming the AI work, and the audit article shows what a separate AI report has to contain. If your current SEO agency can answer those, keep them and add the second report. If they cannot, you need the second job done by someone who can, and ideally by someone who will also take over the first.

What "separately reported" means in practice

Separately reported means two scores from the same scan, each with its own lines. Our own report puts search health, which covers on-page quality, speed, Core Web Vitals, crawl errors and SSL, beside the AI readiness score, which covers whether the engines name you, your entity data, the evidence on your pages, machine readability and crawler access. The two share crawler access and little else. A client can see in one page that the site is fast and unnamed, or slow and cited, and both happen. The SEO vs GEO article goes deeper into why the two scores move independently.

Frequently asked questions

Not if Google matters to you. Google's AI Overviews build on organic rankings, and Google says eligibility in Search is the precondition. Skipping SEO removes you from the largest AI surface there is. It is a re-weighting, not a replacement.

Can I skip AI search and only do SEO?

You can, and you will keep your Google positions while ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini name someone else. Because standalone assistants draw from a different source pool, page one on Google is not a ticket to the answer.

Partly. Links still drive organic discovery and therefore eligibility for Google's AI features. For being named by assistants, brand mentions across the web matter more than the domain score those links raise. A sensible plan keeps links for discovery and adds mentions for recognition.

Will the same content work for both?

Largely, if it carries evidence. A page with specific claims, numbers, definitions and sources ranks and gets absorbed; a page that only repeats keywords does neither well. The editing goal changes from placement to substance.

How do I know my SEO agency is not just relabelling?

Ask for the AI report: engines queried, runs per query, mention rate, competitors named instead. If the answer is a rankings export with a new heading, it is a relabel. The audit article lists what the report has to contain.

What if I am a small local business?

Then the AI job is often smaller than the SEO job. Niche businesses are ranked on what the engines retrieve, so a handful of well-evidenced pages and consistent business data do most of the work. Our small business article covers it.

See both scores for your site

The free analysis produces the two reports side by side for your domain: search health, and whether ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude and Gemini name you for your category. That tells you which job needs doing first, and whether one team is doing both.